Posted by Darren (208.143.232.66) on May 28, 2003 at 10:13:47:
In Reply to: Re: Why Nobody Interest to My Patent? posted by Lurker on May 23, 2003 at 12:59:52:
: Well, Darren, I have heard those theories before, but It doesn't seem very realistic.
Okay, but that's a matter of opinion.
: You say building a Bessler wheel is not easy. Maybe it DOES require SOME skill with carpentry and such, but the fact is that Bessler himself worked with VERY primitive tools and technology. Thus, it can't be all that difficult.
I didn't mean it was hard to swing a hammer, or that you needed a CNC tooling machine, I meant the physics calculations and math are difficult.
: If Bessler was able to build such a wheel hundreds of years ago, then building one today should be very easy.
Yes, building easy... designing hard.
: Your second theory that everyone who is qualified to build a Bessler wheel is also 100% convinced that it is impossible is simply not true as I understand it. There are MANY very good and highly trained scientists all over the world who have sincerely considered the possibilities of various perpetual motion and "over-unity" devices. In addition to that, there are THOUSANDS of highly competant backyard inventors who experiment with these sorts of things. Many claim to have discovered various secrets of one sort or another, and some have even supposedly been verified by competant scientists, yet for SOME reason, these "secrets" never see the light of day.
Again, matter of opinion. You say the trained ones have put some serious effort into it, I say the serious ones gave up a long time ago... you say the backyard guys have the required skills, I say they don't. It's just opinion.
: Now, I want you to consider the possibility that some of these claims are true.
Consinder that some of these claims are true? and surpressed? MIB again? Nah.
: I shouldn't have to twist your arm to do that, considering the nature of this forum. If some of these ARE true, then we can only conclude that the two reasons you give cannot explain why they are still "secret" even though large numbers of people already know about them.
I still stick to my original statements... those who are most qualified don't believe it's possible, and those who do believe it's possible make too many errors. Obviously there's going to be those who don't fit in either catagory, but it's still the strongest argument (at least to me).
Darren